Canadian folk singer and songwriter Joni Mitchell was one of the early successful female solo artists within Western popular music. She is a powerful figure within women in popular music, precisely because “she exemplifies the singer songwriter who got there on her own efforts, and whose albums demonstrate an increasing level of artistic and technical control” (79). Not only was she a recognized and well-respected musician within the folk scene, her second album Clouds (1967) helped her achieve a grammy, signifying commercial success and critical acclaim as well. Her music is very personal, touching on aspects on her life such as her first marriage, the child she gave up for adoption and her struggle as a female musician within a male-dominated music industry. She sings of travelling and being true to herself, and realizing the limitations and unhappiness that men have brought to her life.
Her 1967 album Blue, explores these issues, with special emphasis on her personal struggle with living her life and her musical career on her own terms. The first track of the album, ‘All I Want,’ is indicative of this struggle. Within her very personal lyrics, she comes to the realization that her dependence on men and relationships come at the cost of herself—her dreams, ambitions, life and even happiness. The album describes the “conflict between love and pain, belong and freedom, the resultant emptiness that can accompany the ‘lonely road’” (90). Her intimate portrayal of her struggle through music is what makes her such a powerful female musician. “Her strength lies in her pragmatism” (90) argues Whiteley, noting Mitchell’s realistic, genuine and unromantic view of her life as both a woman and a female musician. Her honest exploration of her personal life through music is essentially what makes her an important female musician.
***
I was always a sucker for the romanticized, idyllic love songs that are so pervasive in popular music. Although the days when I spent hours listening to cheesy love songs are largely over, the raspy voice of Sam Bean from the indie band Iron and Wine continues to pull me into a romantic daydreams. Romantic notions of heterosexual love continue to be major themes within popular music; this practice does not seem to have died out since the heydey of The Beatles and Donavan.
It is interesting then to look at Joni Mitchell and her realistic, pragmatic viewpoint of love, relationships and life as what makes her such a prominent figure within music. Her haunting voice and the lonely sounds of her acoustic guitar help to bring a more down-to-earth tone to her music. Would more realistic versions of life for women within the lyrics of female musicians help to challenge traditional ideas surrounding women and femininity?
As compelling and challenging a musician Joni Mitchell is, I wonder if the image of a "realistic" woman also has it's constraints? Mitchell's reality, portrayed through her songs and lyrics, are just that: one woman's experience of 'reality.' Can we really expect one woman's notion of what "real" women deal with to encompass the experience of all women? Although I feel it is important to challenge overly romanticized versions of femininity and the lives of women, I also feel it is important to recognize the separate realities all women live.
Her 1967 album Blue, explores these issues, with special emphasis on her personal struggle with living her life and her musical career on her own terms. The first track of the album, ‘All I Want,’ is indicative of this struggle. Within her very personal lyrics, she comes to the realization that her dependence on men and relationships come at the cost of herself—her dreams, ambitions, life and even happiness. The album describes the “conflict between love and pain, belong and freedom, the resultant emptiness that can accompany the ‘lonely road’” (90). Her intimate portrayal of her struggle through music is what makes her such a powerful female musician. “Her strength lies in her pragmatism” (90) argues Whiteley, noting Mitchell’s realistic, genuine and unromantic view of her life as both a woman and a female musician. Her honest exploration of her personal life through music is essentially what makes her an important female musician.
***
I was always a sucker for the romanticized, idyllic love songs that are so pervasive in popular music. Although the days when I spent hours listening to cheesy love songs are largely over, the raspy voice of Sam Bean from the indie band Iron and Wine continues to pull me into a romantic daydreams. Romantic notions of heterosexual love continue to be major themes within popular music; this practice does not seem to have died out since the heydey of The Beatles and Donavan.
It is interesting then to look at Joni Mitchell and her realistic, pragmatic viewpoint of love, relationships and life as what makes her such a prominent figure within music. Her haunting voice and the lonely sounds of her acoustic guitar help to bring a more down-to-earth tone to her music. Would more realistic versions of life for women within the lyrics of female musicians help to challenge traditional ideas surrounding women and femininity?
As compelling and challenging a musician Joni Mitchell is, I wonder if the image of a "realistic" woman also has it's constraints? Mitchell's reality, portrayed through her songs and lyrics, are just that: one woman's experience of 'reality.' Can we really expect one woman's notion of what "real" women deal with to encompass the experience of all women? Although I feel it is important to challenge overly romanticized versions of femininity and the lives of women, I also feel it is important to recognize the separate realities all women live.
No comments:
Post a Comment